Parental rights, best interests and significant harms: Medical decision-making on behalf of children post – Great Ormond Street Hospital v Yates [2017]

Dr Imogen Goold1

1Associate Professor and Admissions Co-Ordinator, Faculty of Law, University of Oxford, Fellow and Tutor in Law, St Anne’s College

Who should have the ultimate say over a child’s medical treatment? Gard and Yates argued that in cases where there is a choice of treatments, parents should be the final arbiter of a child’s medical care unless their decision puts the child at risk of significant harm. Both the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court rejected this argument, affirming their authority to intervene in any parental decisions where a child’s welfare is affected and reiterating that the decision must be taken in the child’s best interests. We argue that they (like many courts before them) wrongly elided the question of when the court should intervene with that of how an intervening court should make decisions, (namely in the child’s best interests). We argue that the courts need to offer more justification for the current low threshold for intervention and consider whether some medical decisions should be reserved to parents. We argue for a move to a harm threshold for judicial intervention.

About the Association

The Australasian Association of Bioethics and Health Law (AABHL) was formed in 2009.

It encourages open discussion and debate on a range of bioethical issues, providing a place where people can ask difficult questions about ideas and practices associated with health and illness, biomedical research and human values.

The AABHL seeks to foster a distinctive Australasian voice in bioethics, and provide opportunities for international engagement through its membership, journal and conferences.

Members come from all the contributing humanities, social science and science disciplines that make up contemporary bioethics.

Many members have cross-disciplinary interests and all seek to broaden the dialogues in which all members of the wider community ultimately have an interest.

The AABHL is a supportive, creative and challenging community that provides a rich source of continuing academic refreshment and renewal.

Conference Managers

Please contact the team at Conference Design with any questions regarding the conference.

Photo Credits: Tourism Tasmania, Sean Fennessy, Luke Tscharke, Jess Bonde, Richard Strong, Jason Charles Hill,

© 2015 - 2016 Conference Design Pty Ltd